[patch] Add line_arrangement to power supports presets

[francois.lacombe]

Dear maintainers,

The key line_arrangement has been very recently reviewed on the wiki and received an approval vote.
​https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:line_arrangement
It allows to describe how power lines are geometrically arranged on their supports.

The post-vote cleanup is in progress and documentation is currently under completion.
It may be great to update JOSM presets as follow:

• Add the key with its eight values (horizontal, semi_horizontal, vertical, semi_vertical, triangular, delta, square and unarranged) on power and utility supports presets power=tower, power=pole, power=insulator, power=portal and power=terminal and man_made=utility_pole
• Warn about the use of line_arrangement on any other feature than a node.

Feel free to ask for any unclear point, all the best

François

[taylor.smock]

The post-vote cleanup is in progress and documentation is currently under completion.

Can you ping me when this is done? I don't want to add tags where the documentation is currently in flux, even if it is the result of a vote and should therefore be fairly well documented; I don't want to read something that is outdated and make an easily avoidable mistake.

[francois.lacombe]

Hi

Documentation in English is now stable, it's mostly about translation currently.
It is a brand new key, no outdated content was available before. The wiki was took out of the proposal.

All the best

[taylor.smock]

Reading the documentation, this looks like it will be fairly easy to support.

[gaben]

@francois.lacombe: What do you recon, in what order the line_arrangement, line_attachment and line_management should be presented in the presets?

[francois.lacombe]

Hello

It's a good question. It may be good to put line_arrangement between the other two:

• line_attachment
• line_arrangement
• line_management

Best regards

[gaben]

Oops, I forgot to change the file name.

Anyway, changes:

• added line_arrangement values from wiki
• added a line_properties chunk for line_* values
• disabled lexicographical sorting, use the predefined order for
  • line_arrangement (order by wiki) and
  • line_attachment (order by usage count)

Edit: Also not added to man_made=utility_pole, it's intentional. I'm hesitant to add it since the preset is universal and I don't know if it would confuse users.

[francois.lacombe]

Hello

I don't know if it would confuse users.

I guess not: it's documented
​https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:man_made%3Dutility_pole

[gaben]

Thank you! I added line_properties to man_made=utility_pole.

[francois.lacombe]

That's really great, thank you!

[taylor.smock]

In 18834/josm:

Fix #23149: Add line_arrangement to power supports presets (patch by gaben)

[taylor.smock]

Ticket retargeted after milestone deleted

[taylor.smock]

Ticket retargeted after milestone deleted