false multipolygon warning on boundary relations

[skyper]

Changing a multipolygon relation in a boundary relation is not recognized in validator

1. download a multipolygon boundary relation
2. change its type from multipolygon to boundary
3. add a node with role "label"
4. upload

I get a strange warning about wrong object in multipolygon relation.

r5241

[simon04]

This is closely related to #7550.

[skyper]

Replying to simon04:

This is closely related to #7550.

Yes, but the message is irritating as type=boundary might be a multipolygon but not a multipolygon-relation (type=multipolygon)

[skyper]

Please, if we silently change to relation=boundary we should also make a difference in validator. I got this warning again and searched for the multipolygon to change it into a boundary only to find a correct relation=boundary.

• There is also no hint about the relation as only a the "wrong" object is mentioned which is cumbersome if this object is incomplete. You can not select the relation nor download the incomplete node from validator toggle dialog.

[jjaf.de]

[4219/josm] made admin_centre known to the validator-test. Now we need label at the same place otherwise a false positive of "Non-Way in multipolygon" is thrown.

[skyper]

Ticket #9083 has been marked as a duplicate of this ticket.

[aceman]

The patch in [4219/josm] does not seem difficult to adapt. Could this be fixed for all the special member roles of boundary relation? It reports unnecessary warnings for all existing administrative boundaries in my country.

[stoecker]

In 6239/josm:

fix #7713 - do not warn about label role

[stoecker]

Milestone renamed