Verify properly tagged islands and islets

[naoliv]

​http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:place#Other_places says:

place=island → area > 1 km²
place=islet → area < 1 km²

area:closed[place = islet][eval(areasize()) > 1000] {
        throwWarning: tr("islet with wrong classification");
        suggestAlternative: "place=island";
        fixAdd: "place=island";
}

area:closed[place = island][eval(areasize()) < 1000] {
        throwWarning: tr("island with wrong classification");
        suggestAlternative: "place=islet";
        fixAdd: "place=islet";
}

island|islet with exactly 1 km² is in limbo.
It needs a better warning message, probably.

But it needs to have #11516 fixed to also work with relations.

Is it interesting to have this test in JOSM?

[bastiK]

Wiki page ​Tag:place=islet:

An islet is a very small island with an area less than about 1 km².

The size is only a guiding value, there should be some tolerance.

[naoliv]

Or at info level, saying that the place should probably be island|islet

[Klumbumbus]

What about change the values to 500 and 1500?

area:closed[place = islet][eval(areasize()) > 1500] {
        throwWarning: tr("{0} on a large area", "{1.tag}");
        suggestAlternative: "place=island";
        fixAdd: "place=island";
}

area:closed[place = island][eval(areasize()) < 500] {
        throwWarning: tr("{0} on a small area", "{1.tag}");
        suggestAlternative: "place=islet";
        fixAdd: "place=islet";
}

[Don-vip]

Replying to Klumbumbus:

What about change the values to 500 and 1500?

sounds nice

[Klumbumbus]

In 9843/josm:

fix #12496 - Verify properly tagged islands and islets (modified patch by naoliv)

[Klumbumbus]

In 10328/josm:

fix #12916, see #12496 - fix islet/island size warning

[anonymous]

What are these 500 and 1500?? I have an islet ~7500m² that's 0.0075km² and validator is suggesting place=island
josm version 10327

[anonymous]

Replying to anonymous:

What are these 500 and 1500?? I have an islet ~7500m² that's 0.0075km² and validator is suggesting place=island
josm version 10327

Ok, there is new values in 10328. I should have read all the coments.