Popular tags not in internal presets

[Don-vip]

I have built the list of popular tags (as defined by taginfo), unknown from JOSM presets, for which we do not have a MapCSS deprecation warning.

We should decide which tags should be added to presets, which ones should be deprecated and which ones should be ignored by the tag/key not in presets validator test. The decision that a tag is ignored is not forever and can of course be reconsidered later.

Tag (wiki)	Count (taginfo)	Decision
​abandoned=yes	​19932	Ignored. Lifecycle
​amenity=swimming_pool	​46883	Ignored. Duplicate of leisure=swimming_pool. However not declared as deprecated in the wiki.
​bicycle=dismount	​37307	Ignored for now, see #9158
​bin=yes	​22245
​building=cabin	​89126	Added
​building=civic	​53949
​building=hotel	​21776
​building=houseboat	​11520
​building=kindergarten	​13125
​building=manufacture	​94507
​building=public	​39377
​building=service	​95527
​building=stable	​10477	Added
​building=static_caravan	​26023
​building=train_station	​13938
​construction=yes	​48871	Ignored. Lifecycle
​crop=corn	​13629	Added
​crop=grass	​14186	Added
​crop=rice	​15795	Added
​cuisine=coffee_shop	​16997
​entrance=staircase	​66237
​footway=crossing	​135476
​footway=sidewalk	​217915
​golf=bunker	​64675
​golf=fairway	​24191
​heritage=2	​16686
​heritage=4	​14589
​highway=proposed	​51018	Ignored for now, see #11139
​historic=building	​11875
​historic=yes	​34631	Ignored. Lifecycle
​landuse=conservation	​24867
​landuse=farm	​572939
​leisure=recreation_ground	​27747
​living_street=yes	​193832	Ignored. Used only in Russia. unclear situation in relation to highway=living_street.
​locality=townland	​48104
​maintenance=gritting	​15556	Ignored. Empty wiki page and local usage, see taginfo map
​man_made=mast	​23646
​man_made=petroleum_well	​32326
​man_made=silo	​41194
​military=bunker	​23317
​mooring=yes	​18504	Added
​oneway=-1	​122298	We already have a validator warning.
​oneway=1	​10250	We already have a validator warning.
​pipeline=marker	​12322
​place=allotments	​12582
​placement=right_of:1	​17516	Added
​placement=transition	​12958	Added
​railway=signal	​40435
​railway=stop	​11325
​residential=rural	​125887	Ignored. Used only in Russia. Different concepts of refining residential landuse exist.
​residential=urban	​15335	Ignored. Used only in Russia. Different concepts of refining residential landuse exist.
​route=foot	​26924
​ruins=yes	​33287
​seamark=buoy	​10212
​service=crossover	​16733	Added.
​service=emergency_access	​11623	Added
​smoking=outside	​14449	Added
​surface=earth	​24377	Ignored. Duplicate of ground and dirt (which are used much more) However not declared as deprecated in the wiki.
​takeaway=yes	​17507	Added
​tidal=yes	​16590	Added
​traffic_sign=maxspeed	​19063	Added
​trolley_wire=yes	​34577
​wall=dry_stone	​43074	Added
​wall=no	​10747377	Ignored. Used in French cadastre import
​water=intermittent	​269254	Deprecated. Validator Rule added.
​waterway=rapids	​44573	Difficult case. Was removed from mappaint in r8135 and r8767. The tag is clearly garbage, however there is no replacement, so a deprecation warning is not possible. Keep the situation as is for now.

[Don-vip]

In 9014/josm:

see #12102 - add crop=corn,grass,rice,wheat,hop to landuse=farmland preset

[Don-vip]

In 9015/josm:

see #12102 - add building=cabin,stable to Building preset

[Klumbumbus]

There are some tags, which are neither deprecated, nor are they appropriate to use in a preset imho. Possible reasons are:

• the definition is unclear
• they are mainly used only in one country (and are maybe a result of an import), e.g. wall=no, living_street=yes
• we previously decided to not add them (however we could rethink the dicision), e.g. highway=proposed
• there is a similar tag, tagging scheme is undecided by community, e.g. amenity=swimming_pool, ice cream

Would it be possible to create a list where we add these tags, so they do not appear in the "tag not in presets" warning (info level)?

[Don-vip]

Replying to Klumbumbus:

Would it be possible to create a list where we add these tags, so they do not appear in the "tag not in presets" warning (info level)?

Agreed. Let's update the table with these information for the unclear/ambiguous tags, and I'll code the list.

[Don-vip]

In 9023/josm:

see #12102 - cleanup TagChecker

• code refactor/cleanup/simplification
• clean list of ignored tags by removing tags that have been added to internal presets during past years
• add unit test to detect these tags if we add new tags to internal presets that are currently being ignored

[Don-vip]

In 9024/josm:

see #12102 - ignore Lifecycle tags

[Klumbumbus]

In 9026/josm:

see #12102 - add placement to major road preset

[Klumbumbus]

In 9027/josm:

see #12102 - add takeaway to meal presets

[Klumbumbus]

In 9028/josm:

see #12102 - add tidal to water presets

[Klumbumbus]

In 9029/josm:

see #12102 - add floating and mooring to pier preset

[Klumbumbus]

In 9030/josm:

see #12102 - add some tags to ignore list

[Klumbumbus]

In 9031/josm:

see #12102 - add service=crossover to railway presets and deprecate water=intermittent

[Don-vip]

In 9033/josm:

see #12102 - add wall=dry_stone,noise_barrier to barrier=wall preset

[Don-vip]

In 9034/josm:

see #12102 - add traffic_sign=maxspeed preset

[Don-vip]

In 9035/josm:

see #12102 - add smoking=outside

[Don-vip]

In 9036/josm:

see #12102 - add service=emergency_access to highway=service preset