don't create an associatedStreet-relation as default

[brogo]

Please set the option to create a associatedStreet-relation by default as "disabled".

Many associatedStreet-relation are created accidentially and doesn't contain the needed information (street-member). If someone relly works with aS-relations he can enable this option.

[stephan75]

Indeed we need a change of that feature!

According to the thread in German subforum ​http://forum.openstreetmap.org/viewtopic.php?id=26238 there is an overpass-turbo query how you can display occurence of that wrong relations:

/* choose here any area for that query that can be found by Nominatim */
{{nominatimArea:Bayern}}
(._; )->.area;

/* find all relations of type=associatedStreet */
rel[type=associatedStreet](area.area)->.allASRelations;

/* now find all relations of type=associatedStreet, that have a way as member with role "street" */
way(r.allASRelations:"street");rel(bw:"street")[type=associatedStreet]->.relationsWithRoleStreet;

/* Calculate the difference of these two data pools */
(.allASRelations; - .relationsWithRoleStreet;);

/* choose ways and nodes of that result and display it */
(._; >>;);
out meta;}}}

... so paste this into http://overpass-turbo.eu and execute that query.

[stephan75]

Indeed we need a change of that feature!

According to the thread in German subforum ​http://forum.openstreetmap.org/viewtopic.php?id=26238 there is an overpass-turbo query how you can display occurence of that wrong relations:

/* choose here any area for that query that can be found by Nominatim */
{{nominatimArea:Bayern}}
(._; )->.area;

/* find all relations of type=associatedStreet */
rel[type=associatedStreet](area.area)->.allASRelations;

/* now find all relations of type=associatedStreet, that have a way as member with role "street" */
way(r.allASRelations:"street");rel(bw:"street")[type=associatedStreet]->.relationsWithRoleStreet;

/* Calculate the difference of these two data pools */
(.allASRelations; - .relationsWithRoleStreet;);

/* choose ways and nodes of that result and display it */
(._; >>;);
out meta;

... so paste this into ​http://overpass-turbo.eu and execute that query.

[Klumbumbus]

Please fix this. This bug created thousands of useless and broken associatesStreet relations. (At the moment there are 1791 of these broken relations just in ​Bayern!)
Please atleast set the option to create a associatedStreet relation by default to disabled.
In my opinion it would even be better to completely remove the creation of associatedStreet relations with terracer plugin.

[anonymous]

Bumping this. This is a good feature, and there should be a way to work around this issue somehow.

[skyper]

Well, there are quite some tickets about terracer.

Did not use it lately as it is destroying history and really buggy with associatedStreet relations.

If creating a new relation you need to first check for an already existing relation and then create a proper relation

• how to handle incomplete data (e.g. only part of one street downloaded)
• always add at least one member with role street
  • better use minimum all connected ways with the same name (max all ways with same name in this area)

Core already includes some methods for associatedStreet relations (auto role, validation) and the plugin should use the classes if possible.

[Don-vip]

Fixed in [o30611:30615].